About Us | Subscribe | Contact & Submission info | Volunteer

Alliance Links

Speaking Truth to Power

Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon
Join our FREE Email Mailing List


Front Page

A few words

Arts & Culture






Previous Issues




Ad Rates

More Shannon


The NW Alliance Portal to the NY Times!    


The New York Times Newsletter Logo

Box Covering Columbus Statue in Philadelphia Must Be Removed, Court Rules

The marble statue, a source of division in the city, had been covered by a box in the wake of racial justice protests in 2020.

  • Workers built a plywood box around the statue of Christopher Columbus at Marconi Plaza in South Philadelphia in 2020.
Workers built a plywood box around the statue of Christopher Columbus at Marconi Plaza in South Philadelphia in 2020.Credit...Matt Slocum/Associated Press

By Eduardo Medina

A Pennsylvania court ruled on Friday that the City of Philadelphia must remove the plywood box covering a statue of Christopher Columbus that, in recent years, has been a source of contentious debate over colonialism and heritage.

The 146-year-old marble statue — among the first in the U.S. dedicated to the Italian explorer who sailed to the Americas on behalf of Spain more than 500 years ago — has been particularly divisive in the wake of the murder of George Floyd in 2020, which prompted protests against racial injustice and renewed conversations about polarizing landmarks.

On Friday, a panel of judges in the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania reversed a 2021 decision that had permitted the city to keep its box around the statue, effectively ending officials’ attempt to hide what it considered to be a problematic object.

Judge Mary Hannah Leavitt, who issued the ruling, wrote that the city’s objection to the “message” of the statue was “somewhat opaque” and that if officials wanted to change that, they could do so with a plaque.

She added that the city had accepted the statue as a donation in 1876, during the country’s centennial, meaning that it had a responsibility to preserve the Columbus figure, which was designated a historic object in 2017.

“The Columbus statue,” Judge Leavitt wrote, “is not city property as is, for example, a city snowblower.”

  • Dig deeper into the moment.
Special offer: Subscribe for $1 a week.

Kevin Lessard, a spokesman for the city’s mayor, Jim Kenney, who had sought to remove the statue from Marconi Plaza in 2020 following racial justice protests, said in a statement that “we are very disappointed in the court’s ruling,” though he said that the city would abide by it.

“We continue to believe that the Christopher Columbus statue, which has been a source of controversy in Philadelphia, should be removed from its current position at Marconi Plaza,” Mr. Lessard said. “We are continuing to review the court’s latest ruling and are working to comply with the court’s orders, including unboxing.”

The group that sought to preserve the statue and sued the city to unbox it, Friends of Marconi Plaza, did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment on Friday night. But a lawyer representing the group, George Bochetto, told The Philadelphia Inquirer that he was “delighted” with the court’s decision.

The legal back-and-forth surrounding the 10-foot-tall statue came at a time when other statues are being taken down in American cities including Boston; Richmond, Va.; and St. Paul, Minn.

While supporters of the statue in Philadelphia have argued that it is a source of pride for people with Italian heritage, critics have said that Columbus’s arrival in the New World led to the genocide and exploitation of Indigenous populations in the Americas — a history void of reasons to celebrate the man.

Mr. Kenney appeared to agree with that sentiment on June 15, 2020, when he wrote to the city’s public art director that Columbus’s “history must be accounted for when considering whether to erect or maintain a monument to this person,” according to court documents.

The Historical Commission in Philadelphia held a public hearing on the matter later that summer, with more than 180 people voicing their opinions over six hours.

The commission recommended that the statue be removed “to advance public safety and to protect the statue,” according to court documents.

But Friends of Marconi Plaza quickly disputed that directive, saying in court that the group’s members had been “active caretakers” of the plaza for 10 years and had a direct interest in the future of the statue.

The city argued that because individuals in the group did not own property adjacent to the Columbus statue, they could not demonstrate a “particularized impact on their use and enjoyment of their property” if the statue were removed. The argument did not appear to persuade the judges.

July 24, 2020

Why Some Italian-Americans Still Fiercely Defend Columbus Day

Oct. 5, 2018

Indigenous Peoples’ Day, Explained

Eduardo Medina is a reporter covering breaking news. @byEduardoMedina


Pamela Paul

The Far Right and Far Left Agree on One Thing: Women Don’t Count

Tolerance for one group doesn’t need to mean intolerance for another.

David Brooks

Why on Earth Is Pelosi Supporting the Trumpists?

The moral idiocy of promoting the extremists.

Farah Stockman

The Democrat Who’s Flipping the Campaign Script

A candidate for Congress is speaking out against the government red tape that is reviled in parts of rural America.

Mara Gay

The Republican War on Sex

In the America where I came of age, I was told my life was worth more than my ability to have babies. And my sexuality was nothing to be ashamed of.

Paul Krugman

Why Did Republicans Become So Extreme?

It’s all about resentment of what makes America great.

The Mini Crossword
Solve this bite-sized puzzle in just a few minutes.

Game Icon

Spelling Bee
How many words can you make with 7 letters?

Game Icon

Guess the 5-letter word with 6 chances.

Game Icon

See all our games


Shannon Wheeler's  Too Much Coffee Man Portal  at The Portland Alliance


Navigation: FrontPage / Activism / Interactive Calendar / Donate / Flyer / YouTube / Poster / Subscribe / Place Ad / Ad Rates /
                  Online Ads / Advertising
/ Twitter / News! / Previous Issues / Blog/ Myspace / Facebook1 / Facebook2

Features:   Active Community / A Few Words /Arts & Culture / Breaking News / Jobs /  / Labor History / MusicNewsBytes /
Progressive Directory / Cartoons / Community CalendarLetters / Poetry / Viewpoints & Commentary

ColumnsBeeman, Brown, Engelhardt / Kucinich / Munk / Myers / William Reed / Schwebke / Norman Solomon / Vorpahl / Wittner

Partners: AFD / AMA / Bread&Roses / CAUSA/ CLG/ Common Dreams / DIA / FSP /ISO / Jobs w\ Justice / KBOO / Labor Radio / LGBTQMRG / Milagro / Mosaic / Move-On / OccupyOEA / Occupy PDX / Peace House / The 99% / Peace worker / PCASC / PPRCRight 2 Dream Too / Street Roots / Skanner / The Nation / TruthOut / Urban League / VFP / Voz /

Topics: A-F AIPAC / Civil Rights / Coal / Death Penalty / Education / Election 2012 / Fair Trade / F-29 / Environment / Foreclosure /

 Topics:  G-R
Health / Homeless / J-Street / Middle East / Occupy Blog / Peace / Persian / Police / Post Office

Topics: S-Z STRIKE! /  The New York Times: http://www.ThePortlandAlliance.org/nytpa
Tri-Met /  Union / VDay / War & Peace / Women / Writing / WritingResource

Newer and Updated Pages:      http://www.ThePortlandAlliance.org/physics   

“Your reward will be the widening of the horizon as you climb. And if you achieve that reward, you will ask no other.”   ― Cecilia Payne-Gaposchkin  


Haiti: Celebrating the New Year and Independence    

 Hollywood Theatre!  http://www.ThePortlandAlliance.org/copwatch 

AFRICA NEWS:   http://www.ThePortlandAlliance.org/africa   http://www.ThePortlandAlliance.org/indybay   

ThePortlandAlliance.org/MyLai  /  http://www.ThePortlandAlliance.org/PICA 

   http://www.ThePortlandAlliance.org/2018/November  http://www.theportlandalliance.org/breakingnews  

 Indymedia Portal   http://www.ThePortlandAlliance.org/indymediaportal   Hollywood Theatre! 

  http://www.ThePortlandAlliance.org/copwatch   AFRICA NEWS:   http://www.ThePortlandAlliance.org/africa 

ThePortlandAlliance.org/MyLai   http://www.ThePortlandAlliance.org/PICA 


A Scientist Who Resisted Trump Administration Censorship of Climate Report Just Lost Her Job 
“I wouldn’t do anything different, but Jesus, this is stressful.”


The Portland Alliance:
Phone Number: Cell (for emergencies) 503-697-1670
For questions, comments, or suggestions for this site, please contact editor@theportlandalliance.org or ThePortlandAlliance@gmail.com
© 1981-2022 NAAME Northwest Alliance for Alternative Media & Education, dba The Portland Alliance:
All Rights Reserved.  A 501C3 Oregon Non-profit Corporation for Public Benefit

Support local media:
The Asian Reporter | Kboo | The Oregon Peaceworker | Portland.Indymedia.org | The Skanner